You've found some resources for your paper, but how do you know if they're appropriate? Try these five criteria to help evaluate sources:
Purpose
• What stated goals or objectives does this resource meet?
• Is its purpose commercial, educational, informative or personal?
• How detailed and factual is the information versus opinion-based?
• Is the information balanced or colored with a political, commercial, or
religious point of view?
|
Authority
• If a website, does the domain indicate what type of institution published it?
• Is the resource from a peer-reviewed (also called scholarly or academic) journal or
published by a scholarly or educational organization?
• Is the author identifiable?
• Does the author/publisher list qualifications, and can they be verified?
|
Accuracy
• Does the author provide factual information verifiable in other resources?
• Is the information clear, legible, well organized and error-free?
• Does the author cite his/her sources? Are research methods explained?
• Is an editor, reviewer or collaborator named who verified content?
|
Coverage
• Are topics in this resource analyzed in depth or just summarized?
• Does the resource cover all aspects of a topic or state the criteria for
select coverage?
• Does this work substantiate other sources or update other information?
|
Currency
• When was the resource produced and/or updated?
• If the resource is a website, are the links active and current?
• Is the resource referenced by other sources?
|
This guide was adapted from a resource available at Indiana Wesleyan University.